Hello,
I am trying to set up a stunnel between two machines running LynxOS, which is a POSIX derivative.
I've compiled OpenSSL 0.9.8e, and stunnel 4.20:
stunnel 4.20 on i386-unknown-lynxos with OpenSSL 0.9.8e 23 Feb 2007 Threading:FORK SSL:ENGINE Sockets:POLL,IPv4 [...]
I use the following config files:
////// server side debug=7 foreground=yes pid=
CAfile=valid_certs key=privkey.pem cert=cert.pem verify=1
[SSLTunnel] accept=1235 connect=1234 ////// end server side
////// client side debug=7 foreground=yes pid=
CAfile=valid_certs key=privkey.pem cert=cert.pem verify=1
client=yes
[SSLTunnel] accept=4234 connect=173.16.1.10:1235 ////// end client side
(It's run from different directories so the PEM files are different)
After running both stunnels, I connect to the client side and see a beginning of handshake; however, it then breaks down: from afar, it looks like the client doesn't take the server certificate:
///// server trace 2007.04.25 15:33:22 LOG7[58:0]: Snagged 64 random bytes from /home/st07815/.rnd 2007.04.25 15:33:22 LOG7[58:0]: Wrote 1024 new random bytes to /home/st07815/.rnd 2007.04.25 15:33:22 LOG7[58:0]: RAND_status claims sufficient entropy for the PRNG 2007.04.25 15:33:22 LOG7[58:0]: PRNG seeded successfully 2007.04.25 15:33:22 LOG7[58:0]: Certificate: cert.pem 2007.04.25 15:33:22 LOG7[58:0]: Certificate loaded 2007.04.25 15:33:22 LOG7[58:0]: Key file: privkey.pem 2007.04.25 15:33:22 LOG7[58:0]: Private key loaded 2007.04.25 15:33:22 LOG7[58:0]: Loaded verify certificates from valid_certs 2007.04.25 15:33:22 LOG7[58:0]: Loaded valid_certs revocation lookup file 2007.04.25 15:33:22 LOG7[58:0]: SSL context initialized for service SSLTunnel 2007.04.25 15:33:22 LOG5[58:0]: stunnel 4.20 on i386-unknown-lynxos with OpenSSL 0.9.8e 23 Feb 2007 2007.04.25 15:33:22 LOG5[58:0]: Threading:FORK SSL:ENGINE Sockets:POLL,IPv4 2007.04.25 15:33:22 LOG6[58:0]: file ulimit = 64 (can be changed with 'ulimit -n') 2007.04.25 15:33:22 LOG6[58:0]: poll() used - no FD_SETSIZE limit for file descriptors 2007.04.25 15:33:22 LOG5[58:0]: 29 clients allowed 2007.04.25 15:33:22 LOG7[58:0]: FD 3 in non-blocking mode 2007.04.25 15:33:22 LOG7[58:0]: FD 4 in non-blocking mode 2007.04.25 15:33:22 LOG7[58:0]: FD 5 in non-blocking mode 2007.04.25 15:33:22 LOG7[58:0]: SO_REUSEADDR option set on accept socket 2007.04.25 15:33:22 LOG7[58:0]: SSLTunnel bound to 0.0.0.0:1235 2007.04.25 15:33:22 LOG7[58:0]: No pid file being created (end of init, waiting for connection) 2007.04.25 15:34:17 LOG7[58:0]: SSLTunnel accepted FD=6 from 173.16.1.7:1092 2007.04.25 15:34:17 LOG7[68:0]: SSLTunnel started 2007.04.25 15:34:17 LOG7[68:0]: FD 6 in non-blocking mode 2007.04.25 15:34:17 LOG5[68:0]: SSLTunnel accepted connection from 173.16.1.7:1092 2007.04.25 15:34:17 LOG7[68:0]: SSL state (accept): before/accept initialization 2007.04.25 15:34:17 LOG7[68:0]: SSL state (accept): SSLv3 read client hello A 2007.04.25 15:34:17 LOG7[68:0]: SSL state (accept): SSLv3 write server hello A 2007.04.25 15:34:17 LOG7[68:0]: SSL state (accept): SSLv3 write certificate A 2007.04.25 15:34:17 LOG7[68:0]: SSL state (accept): SSLv3 write certificate request A 2007.04.25 15:34:17 LOG7[68:0]: SSL state (accept): SSLv3 flush data 2007.04.25 15:34:19 LOG3[68:0]: SSL_accept: Peer suddenly disconnected 2007.04.25 15:34:19 LOG5[68:0]: Connection reset: 0 bytes sent to SSL, 0 bytes sent to socket 2007.04.25 15:34:19 LOG7[58:0]: Cleaning up the signal pipe 2007.04.25 15:34:19 LOG7[58:0]: Process 68 finished with code 0 (0 left) ///// end server trace
///// client trace 2007.04.25 15:33:59 LOG7[12:0]: Snagged 64 random bytes from /home/st07815/.rnd 2007.04.25 15:33:59 LOG7[12:0]: Wrote 1024 new random bytes to /home/st07815/.rnd 2007.04.25 15:33:59 LOG7[12:0]: RAND_status claims sufficient entropy for the PRNG 2007.04.25 15:33:59 LOG7[12:0]: PRNG seeded successfully 2007.04.25 15:33:59 LOG7[12:0]: Certificate: cert.pem 2007.04.25 15:33:59 LOG7[12:0]: Certificate loaded 2007.04.25 15:33:59 LOG7[12:0]: Key file: privkey.pem 2007.04.25 15:33:59 LOG7[12:0]: Private key loaded 2007.04.25 15:33:59 LOG7[12:0]: Loaded verify certificates from valid_certs 2007.04.25 15:33:59 LOG7[12:0]: Loaded valid_certs revocation lookup file 2007.04.25 15:33:59 LOG7[12:0]: SSL context initialized for service SSLTunnel 2007.04.25 15:33:59 LOG5[12:0]: stunnel 4.20 on i386-unknown-lynxos with OpenSSL 0.9.8e 23 Feb 2007 2007.04.25 15:33:59 LOG5[12:0]: Threading:FORK SSL:ENGINE Sockets:POLL,IPv4 2007.04.25 15:33:59 LOG6[12:0]: file ulimit = 64 (can be changed with 'ulimit -n') 2007.04.25 15:33:59 LOG6[12:0]: poll() used - no FD_SETSIZE limit for file descriptors 2007.04.25 15:33:59 LOG5[12:0]: 29 clients allowed 2007.04.25 15:33:59 LOG7[12:0]: FD 3 in non-blocking mode 2007.04.25 15:33:59 LOG7[12:0]: FD 4 in non-blocking mode 2007.04.25 15:33:59 LOG7[12:0]: FD 5 in non-blocking mode 2007.04.25 15:33:59 LOG7[12:0]: SO_REUSEADDR option set on accept socket 2007.04.25 15:33:59 LOG7[12:0]: SSLTunnel bound to 0.0.0.0:4234 2007.04.25 15:33:59 LOG7[12:0]: No pid file being created (end of init, waiting for connection) 2007.04.25 15:34:27 LOG7[12:0]: SSLTunnel accepted FD=6 from 152.14.101.54:64752 2007.04.25 15:34:27 LOG7[27:0]: SSLTunnel started 2007.04.25 15:34:27 LOG7[27:0]: FD 6 in non-blocking mode 2007.04.25 15:34:27 LOG5[27:0]: SSLTunnel accepted connection from 152.14.101.54:64752 2007.04.25 15:34:27 LOG7[27:0]: FD 5 in non-blocking mode 2007.04.25 15:34:27 LOG7[27:0]: SSLTunnel connecting 173.16.1.10:1235 2007.04.25 15:34:27 LOG7[27:0]: connect_wait: waiting 10 seconds 2007.04.25 15:34:27 LOG7[27:0]: connect_wait: connected 2007.04.25 15:34:27 LOG5[27:0]: SSLTunnel connected remote server from 173.16.1.7:1092 2007.04.25 15:34:27 LOG7[27:0]: Remote FD=5 initialized 2007.04.25 15:34:27 LOG7[27:0]: SSL state (connect): before/connect initialization 2007.04.25 15:34:27 LOG7[27:0]: SSL state (connect): SSLv3 write client hello A 2007.04.25 15:34:27 LOG7[27:0]: SSL state (connect): SSLv3 read server hello A 2007.04.25 15:34:28 LOG7[12:0]: Cleaning up the signal pipe 2007.04.25 15:34:28 LOG7[12:0]: Process 27 terminated on signal 11 (0 left) ///// end client trace
Now the strange thing is that this very same setup works on Solaris, so I have something wrong with the port of either OpenSSL or stunnel on LynxOS.
If someone could give me a hint as to where to start poking, I'd greatly appreciate it.
TIA, Y.
RUTSCHLE Yves wrote:
2007.04.25 15:34:28 LOG7[12:0]: Cleaning up the signal pipe 2007.04.25 15:34:28 LOG7[12:0]: Process 27 terminated on signal 11 (0 left)
[cut]
If someone could give me a hint as to where to start poking, I'd greatly appreciate it.
Disable TCP wrappers library support: ./configure --disable-libwrap make clean make make install Please let us know if it works fine, now.
Best regards, Mike
Michal Trojnara wrote:
If someone could give me a hint as to where to start poking, I'd greatly appreciate it.
Disable TCP wrappers library support: ./configure --disable-libwrap make clean make make install Please let us know if it works fine, now.
It does. Why, thank you very much, I just wanted a hint you have have a solution :-)
However I'd be interested in what you think was the problem.
As I received your suggestion, I was going through the OpenSSL code and the point I reached in my investigation is that during certificate verification, the call to X509_time_adj (openssl:crypto/x509/x509_vfy.c) never returns. Not sure if the problem was in ASN1_UTCTIME or what, yet. Either way, what does disabling libwrap do, that would change certificate verification?
Cheers, Y.
-
Michal Trojnara -
RUTSCHLE Yves